Cheese Quest! (The search for strong Swiss Cheese: Part I)

For about six months now (perseverance being the dark side of patience) I’ve been looking for some mouth-wateringly sharp Swiss Cheese.  None of that “mild, nutty taste” for me.  I like Swiss Cheese that has some burn to it; that stays in your mouth for a few minutes like a good pepper.

I probably enjoyed sharp Swiss cheese the most during my years in Cleveland, Ohio, at various delicatessens there, when I was less health conscious and ordered authentic Reubens more often.  On such a strong tasting sandwich a good sharp Swiss can hold its own.  When the urge struck me for a strong Swiss Cheese and I couldn’t find any near my home in Florida, my Cheese Quest was born.

At the outset I have to note that none of the cheeses I’ve bought so far look exactly like their photos, including the best sharp cheese I’ve found so far,  Middlefield Sharp Swiss from Middlefield Cheese in (where else?) Middlefield, Ohio.

The eyes in this cheese are smaller that pictured, but the cheese is pretty sharp and has a “real” Swiss cheese taste.

Another good cheese was the 2 Year Aged Swiss from Wisconsin Cheese Mart, an Amazon store.

But neither of these has the bite that I’m looking for, nor the iconic large eyes, so the Quest goes on.  By all means contact me with sources of good sharp Swiss Cheese, especially in cooler months when they can be most readily shipped to warmer climes.

(next: a few notes and two sharp cheese I won’t buy again)

On the Internet the best search terms appear to be “aged Swiss Cheese”, “2 year aged Swiss Cheese” and “Sharp Swiss Cheese”.   Until you consider the fact that I haven’t found that “ideal” cheese yet, so perhaps there are even better search terms.

I’ve learned that the size of the “eyes” (the holes in Swiss Cheese) are one sign of aging, and therefore possibly also of sharpness.  However, because these large eyed cheeses don’t slice well for mass market packaging, they have been discouraged in America.

There are two cheeses I won’t order again.

The first is the 2 Year Aged Swiss from Paoli Cheese.  It’s pretty strong and Swiss like, but many of the eyes contain liquid or residue (friendly cheese-making bacteria, I presume).

Sharp Swiss from Shisler’s Cheese House is one of the stronger cheeses, but tastes and looks the least like archetypal Swiss Cheese (it doesn’t look at all like their website photo; instead having nearly nonexistent eyes).   Nice people, by the way, but this cheese isn’t what I’m looking for.


About Cornan The Iowan

Science and music are my two great loves. The intricate subtlety of nature and of Bach's counterpoint are two of a kind to me.
This entry was posted in Food and drink. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Cheese Quest! (The search for strong Swiss Cheese: Part I)

  1. Mike McDermid says:

    I too, am looking for a sharp Swiss. Bought a small block of “sharp” Middlefield on line recently. Alas, it does not fill the bill. Looking for one that can hold its own in a corned beef sandwich (on rye with deli mustard). Will try the Wisconsin Cheese mart next.

  2. Chaim Orbach says:

    Hi. I share the same appreciation of sharp Swiss cheese. I however have the added obstacle in that the cheese must be kosher. With that said, I would recommend you try Schmerling Emmental Swiss cheese. I find it to be fairly sharp and leaves that lingering burn that I think you mean.

  3. William Cameron says:

    Yep. Same complaint. Commercial swiss cheese that has all the taste of a ‘white’ American Processed Cheese Food Product. Sigh.

    It’s not as if my wallet can support an unlimited number of imported trial swissies, either.

    I am doomed to die cheese whiz death; while pining away for…something more.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s